Legendary baseball executive Branch Rickey is credited with originating the oft-repeated mantra of general managers that it's better to "trade a player a year too early rather than a year too late."
With that in mind, here's an interesting case study involving three popular former or current Twin Cities athletes who are quite similar in many ways: Brian Dozier, Jason Zucker and Kyle Rudolph.
Dozier had a breakout season in 2016, smashing 42 home runs. But he did it for the 103-loss Twins, and he was the subject of many trade rumors that offseason. The Twins ended up keeping him, and he had another big year in 2017 in helping them to a surprise wild-card berth. But he slumped and the team slumped in 2018, leading him to be traded at the deadline.
Dealing him after the 2016 season would have been a year too early, but the Twins would have surely received more value in hindsight. They also probably wouldn't have made the 2017 postseason.
Zucker had a career-high 33 goals two years ago for the Wild and was the subject of trade rumors last offseason. The Wild instead signed him to a long-term extension, and Zucker slumped to 21 goals this past year. He was nearly traded at the deadline and is a candidate to be traded this offseason — when his value won't be as high as it was last year.
Dealing him last offseason would have been a good business move, but it would have been harder coming off a playoff berth.
The Star Tribune reported Friday that trade rumors involving Rudolph could gain steam now that contract talks between the Vikings and their longtime tight end have broken down.
Rudolph has been a steady performer and doesn't show any obvious signs of slippage, though his Pro Football Focus grade in 2018 was the second-lowest of his eight-year career. His crime is tied more to his salary ($7.625 million in 2019), the availability of cheaper labor (second-round pick Irv Smith Jr.) and the pressure on the salary cap created by the signing of QB Kirk Cousins last year.