Advertisement

Is carbon capture here?

Energy Department aims to slash cost of removing carbon from the air

November 5, 2021 at 11:42PM
Steel igloos cover injection wells that the Icelandic start-up company Carbfix uses to inject carbon dioxide into the earth outside Reykjavik, Iceland, on Oct. 6, 2021. Carbfix has discovered that its CO2 mix will chemically react with basalt and turn to rock in just two or three years instead of the centuries that the mineralization process was believed to take. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
Steel igloos cover injection wells that the Icelandic start-up company Carbfix uses to inject carbon dioxide into the earth outside Reykjavik, Iceland, on Oct. 6, 2021. Carbfix has discovered that its CO2 mix will chemically react with basalt and turn to rock in just two or three years instead of the centuries that the mineralization process was believed to take. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times) (NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Stephan Hitz paused from his work operating an odd-looking machine in an otherworldly landscape in Iceland and reached for a "Star Wars" analogy to explain his job at the frontier of climate technology.

"I feel like I have come from the Dark Side to become a Jedi warrior," he joked as he braced against a chill wind blowing across the treeless stretches of cooled lava and distant volcanoes.

The 37-year-old service technician from Zurich spent nine years working in the aviation and marine industries before joining Climeworks, a Swiss startup that is trying to undo the damage caused by such heavily polluting industries.

"It does give you extra satisfaction to know that you're helping the planet instead of damaging it," he said.

Hitz and his small team of technicians are running Orca, the world's biggest commercial direct air capture (DAC) device, which in September began pulling carbon dioxide out of the air at a site 20 miles from the capital, Reykjavik.

Stephan Hitz, a senior service technician for Climeworks, the Swiss company that made the Orca direct air capture device, working on the machine outside Reykjavik, Iceland on Oct. 6, 2021. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

As the wind stirred up clouds of steam billowing from the nearby Hellisheidi geothermal power plant, a gentle hum came from Orca, which resembles four massive air-conditioners, each the size of one shipping container sitting on top of another.

Each container holds 12 large round fans powered by renewable electricity from the geothermal plant, which suck air into steel catchment boxes where carbon dioxide, or CO2, the main greenhouse gas behind global warming, chemically bonds with a sandlike filtering substance.

Orca sucks air into large containers where a sand-like filtering material extracts the carbon dioxide, outside Reykjavik, Iceland on Oct. 6, 2021. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

When heat is applied to that filtering substance it releases the CO2, which is then mixed with water by an Icelandic company called Carbfix to create a drinkable fizzy water.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Seve

Steel igloos cover injection wells that the Icelandic start-up company Carbfix uses to inject carbon dioxide into the earth outside Reykjavik, Iceland, on Oct. 6, 2021. Carbfix has discovered that its CO2 mix will chemically react with basalt and turn to rock in just two or three years instead of the centuries that the mineralization process was believed to take. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

ral other firms are striving to pull carbon from the air in the United States and elsewhere, but only here in the volcanic plateaus of Iceland is the CO2 being turned into that sparkling cocktail and injected several hundred meters down into basalt bedrock.

Carbfix has discovered that its CO2 mix will chemically react with basalt and turn to rock in just two or three years instead of the centuries that the mineralization process was believed to take, so it takes the CO2 that Climeworks' DAC captures and pumps it into the ground through wells protected from the harsh environment by steel igloos that could easily serve as props in a space movie.

It is a permanent solution, unlike the planting of forests which can release their carbon by rotting, being cut down or burning in a warming planet.

Stephan Hitz, a senior service technician for Climeworks, the Swiss company that made the Orca direct air capture device, outside Reykjavik, Iceland on Oct. 6, 2021. Hitz used to work for the aviation and maritime industries whose emissions the Orca project is now working to remove. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Orca is billed as the world's first commercial DAC unit because the 4,000 metric tons of CO2 it can extract each year have been paid for by 8,000 people who have subscribed online to remove some carbon, and by firms including Stripe, Swiss Re, Audi and Microsoft.

The rock band Coldplay recently joined those companies in paying Climeworks for voluntary carbon credits to offset some of their own emissions.

Advertisement

The problem is that Orca's output equals just three seconds of humanity's annual CO2 emissions, which are closer to 40 billion metric tons, but Orca has at least shown that the concept of scrubbing the air clean and putting carbon back underground has moved from science fiction to science.

Christoph Gebald, Climeworks' co-founder, is adamant that the technology can grow into a trillion-dollar industry in the next three or four decades, a goal that he says would be helped if the United Nations climate conference in Glasgow, Scotland, called COP26, sees most nations commit to net zero emissions by 2050.

The challenge will hinge on reducing costs, which Gebald said are now about $600 to $800 a metric ton. Increased output could bring those costs down to $200 to $300 a metric ton by 2030, and $100 to $150 somewhere around 2035, he said.

DAC would already be competitive if it received the subsidies that helped electric vehicles and solar panels deploy and flourish, Gebald said.

A fundamental difference from wind and solar power is that they were ultimately driven by the profit motive because once subsidies had helped to make them competitive they were producing a valuable asset: cheap electricity.

DAC's main "output" — helping to save the planet — must instead rely on government supports such as emission credits and taxes on carbon emitters, hence the importance of meetings such as the Glasgow conference.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Carbfix is busily exploring how to adapt its mineralization process to other types of rock and how to use seawater at sites that are short of fresh water.

Olafur Ragnar Grimsson, a former president of Iceland, stands for a portrait in Mosfellsbaer, Iceland on Oct. 7, 2021. Olafur Ragnar Grimsson is known as the "fairy godfather" of Orca, which sucks air into large containers where a sand-like filtering material extracts the carbon dioxide. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Carbfix was launched as a research project in 2007 after prodding by the then-president of Iceland, Olafur Ragnar Grimsson, who had been told by a local scientist that Iceland's highly porous basalt could mineralize CO2 without creating any seismic problems.

Grimsson consolidated his role as Orca's "fairy godfather" shortly after ending his 20 years as president in 2016, when he was walking through the bar of a luxury hotel at that year's U.N. climate meeting in Marrakech, Morocco.

"I happened to overhear this American investor sitting at a table loudly boosting this new Swiss company that he said had the technology to pull carbon straight out of the air," he said. "So I stopped and said 'Hey, in Iceland we know how to turn that stuff into rock!'"

He put Gebald together with Carbfix "and bingo, that was the missing link."

Edda Aradottir, the chief executive of Carbfix, stands for a portrait outside Reykjavik, Iceland on Oct. 6, 2021. Carbfix was launched as a research project in 2007 after prodding by the then-president of Iceland, Olafur Ragnar Grimsson, who had been told by a local scientist that Iceland's highly porous basalt could mineralize CO2 without creating any seismic problems. (Sigga Ella/The New York Times)
(NYT/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Despite that lucky accident, Edda Aradottir, the chief executive of Carbfix, said she is not confident that the latest U.N. climate conference will do enough to help "negative emission technologies" live up to their potential.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"Somehow it seems that these events rarely achieve what they set out to do," she said.

Peter Wilson New York Times

Advertisement
about the writer

about the writer

New York Times

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
In this photo taken Monday, March 6, 2017, in San Francisco, released confidential files by The University of California of a sexual misconduct case, like this one against UC Santa Cruz Latin Studies professor Hector Perla is shown. Perla was accused of raping a student during a wine-tasting outing in June 2015. Some of the files are so heavily redacted that on many pages no words are visible. Perla is one of 113 UC employees found to have violated the system's sexual misconduct policies in rece

We respect the desire of some tipsters to remain anonymous, and have put in place ways to contact reporters and editors to ensure the communication will be private and secure.

Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement