If elected, Joe Mauer would join exclusive Hall of Fame catchers club

If Joe Mauer gets elected to baseball’s Hall of Fame on Tuesday, he would become only the third catcher to make it on his first time on the ballot.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
January 22, 2024 at 8:53PM
Johnny Bench, a 1989 first-ballot inductee, did an impersonation of Harry Caray as he sang "Take Me Out To The Ballgame" during Hall of Fame induction ceremonies in 2004. (JOHN DUNN)

Only two catchers have ever been elected by Baseball Writers’ Association of America members to the Hall of Fame on the first ballot: Johnny Bench and Ivan Rodriguez. Joe Mauer hopes to become the third on Tuesday. The voting history of the 18 catchers already enshrined, eight of whom were elected by special committees:

Buck Ewing (inducted in 1939*): 1 year on BBWAA ballot; received 0.7% of the vote on first ballot.

Roger Bresnahan (1945*): 6 years on ballot; received 20.8% on first ballot

Mickey Cochrane (1947): 6 years on ballot; received 35.4% on first ballot

Bill Dickey (1954): 9 years on ballot; received 6.9% on first ballot

Gabby Hartnett (1955): 12 years on ballot; received 0.0% on first ballot

Ray Schalk (1955*): 16 years on ballot; received 1.8% on first ballot

Roy Campanella (1969): 5 years on ballot; received 57.2% on first ballot

Yogi Berra (1972): 2 years on ballot; received 67.2% on first ballot

Josh Gibson (1972**): 0 years on ballot

Rick Ferrell (1984*): 3 years on ballot; received 0.5% on first ballot

Ernie Lombardi (1986*): 9 years on ballot; received 1.8% on first ballot

Johnny Bench (1989): 1 year on ballot; received 96.4% on first ballot

Carlton Fisk (2000): 2 years on ballot; received 66.4% on first ballot

Gary Carter (2003): 6 years on ballot; received 42.3% on first ballot

Louis Santop (2006**): 0 years on ballot

Mike Piazza (2016): 4 years on ballot; 57.8% on first ballot

Iván Rodríguez (2017): 1 year on ballot; 76.0% on first ballot

Ted Simmons (2020*) : 1 year on ballot; 3.7% on first ballot

* — Elected by veterans committee

** — Elected by Negro Leagues committee

about the writer

about the writer

Phil Miller

Reporter

Phil Miller has covered the Twins for the Star Tribune since 2013. Previously, he covered the University of Minnesota football team, and from 2007-09, he covered the Twins for the Pioneer Press.

See More

More from Twins

card image

The St. Petersburg City Council reversed course Thursday on whether to spend more than $23 million to repair the hurricane-shredded roof of the Tampa Bay Rays' ballpark, initially voting narrowly for approval and hours later changing course.

card image