"I could eat an entire carton of these," said my friend.
Same here. He was referring to a showstopping starter that chef Jamie Malone can surely never remove from the menu at her Grand Cafe — a terra cotta-tinted eggshell that's carefully filled with a supple custard, its cream echoing a hint of tobacco and infused with decadent foie gras.
That eccentric deliciousness is capped with whipped crème fraîche seasoned with a bit of cherry vinegar, a cheery pop of orange zest and a single, disciplined flake of sea salt. The combination is as sublime to consume as it is to gaze upon — if foie gras "royale" doesn't have its own Instagram account, it should, because it's that much of a looker — and that it arrives at the table in a facsimile of a duck's foot makes it all the more enchanting.
Turns out, we were just getting started. A delicate choux pastry, gleaming with sticky honey, was split and filled with an earthy, mineral-laden chicken liver mousse. No glazed doughnut will measure up, ever again.
Right now, Malone's somewhat modest menu features one of my favorite vegetarian dishes of the year. It starts with an egg yolk-based, gnocchi-like dough that's formed into long, pinky-esque dumplings and enriched with her secret ingredient/pantry staple, roast garlic purée. They're tossed in a decadent mushroom-Madeira-cream (emphasis on cream) sauce, and it's cold-weather comfort food at its most satisfying.
One of the traits that makes Malone's confident work so compelling is her obvious curiosity for quirky — and superior — ingredients, a passion that reaps untold benefits at the table. This dumpling dish, for example. She finishes that sauce with a fleck of a French-imported black walnut mustard.
"You can't really taste it, but it adds something," she said. "I started using it a couple of years ago, and now I put it in everything."
Her willingness to transcend traditional boundaries is also admirable. While she's capable of a fashioning a straight-up Alsatian classic in the form of a tarte flambée (the crackerlike crust is embellished with crème fraîche, Parmesan, plenty of thyme and massive hunks of Wisconsin-made Nueske's bacon), she's also unafraid to stroll outside the parameters of a modern French restaurant.