Twins vs. Blue Jays: Playoff roster breakdown, wild-card series prediction

A position-by-position breakdown of the Twins and Blue Jays shows which team has the edge in the American League wild-card series at Target Field.

October 3, 2023 at 3:46PM
Royce Lewis, José Berrios and Jhoan Duran are likely to have a big impact on the outcome of the wild-card series between the Twins and Blue Jays. (Star Tribune and AP photos/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

HITTING

Overview: The Twins tied for the American League lead with 233 home runs and were fourth in OPS (.753), but struck out a major league record 1,654 times. Toronto had a better batting average (.253-.246) but scored fewer runs (778-746).

FIRST BASE

Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Blue Jays: Led Toronto in HRs (26) and RBI (94) and was an All-Star for the third consecutive season.

Alex Kirilloff, Twins: Chronic wrist injury no longer a bother, he had opposite-field power and hit 11 HRs with 41 RBI in 88 games.

Edge: Toronto

SECOND BASE

Cavan Biggio, Blue Jays: Lefthanded hitter likely starter vs. righties. Hit .235 with nine HRs. Whit Merrifield could start here; the versatile vet was an All-Star who led the Jays with 26 steals.

Jorge Polanco, Twins: Limited to 80 games because of injury (14 HRs, 48 RBI) and will play third if Royce Lewis can't. Rookie 2B Edouard Julien had an eye-opening season (.840 OPS) but figures to sit if a lefty starts.

Edge: Twins

SHORTSTOP

Bo Bichette, Blue Jays: Hit .306 with 20 HRs and a team-high .814 OPS. Has led the AL in hits twice.

Carlos Correa, Twins: Team's highest-paid player was hampered by plantar fasciitis, hit .230 and grounded into a franchise-record 30 double plays.

Edge: Toronto

THIRD BASE

Matt Chapman, Blue Jays: Dramatic drop in production, from 27 HRs and 76 RBI in 2022 to 17 HRs and 54 RBI this year, but he's a three-time Gold Glove winner.

Royce Lewis, Twins: Showed signs of stardom (.920 OPS, .309 average, 15 HRs in 58 games) in his rookie season, which included four grand slams. Battling hamstring injury, will DH if he can't play in the field.

Edge: Twins

LEFT FIELD

Daulton Varsho, Blue Jays: Acquired in an offseason trade with Arizona, he hit 20 HRs but batted only .222.

Matt Wallner, Twins: Another rookie who emerged as a regular after being called up from St. Paul; he showed ringing power (.507 slugging percentage).

Edge: Twins

CENTER FIELD

Kevin Kiermaier, Blue Jays: Three-time Gold Glove winner known as HR robber hit .265 with six triples in 129 games.

Michael A. Taylor, Twins: Offseason addition to back up Byron Buxton, Taylor was an everyday player when Buxton could only DH. The former Gold Glover had 21 HRs.

Edge: Toronto

RIGHT FIELD

George Springer, Blue Jays: Four-time All-Star and team's highest paid player won a ring with the Astros in 2017; had a career-low .732 OPS.

Max Kepler, Twins: A great second half has Kepler streaking into playoffs. Led the Twins in HRs (24) and RBI (66).

Edge: Twins

CATCHER

Alejandro Kirk, Blue Jays: Coming off an All-Star season, his average fell to .250 and he had only eight HRs in 123 games.

Ryan Jeffers, Twins: Improved defensively, and had breakout offensive season (.276 average, .859 OPS). Could rotate with Christian Vázquez.

Edge: Even

DESIGNATED HITTER

Brandon Belt, Blue Jays: After 12 seasons with the Giants, the lefthanded hitter signed with Toronto and hit 19 HRs in 103 games.

Lewis or Julien, Twins: Lewis' injury might limit him to DHing, but rookie Julien will probably play second if that's the case. Julien has a 2.8 WAR, highest among the team's position players.

Edge: Twins

BENCH

Blue Jays: Biggio played 111 games and seven positions. Whit Merrifield struggled in the second half. Santiago Espinal has been a reliable infielder. C Danny Jansen (17 HRs) is on the IL. 2B Davis Schneider was called up late and had eight HRs in 35 games.

Twins: Kyle Farmer (SS, 3B), Donovan Solano (1B, 2B), Vázquez and Willi Castro (infield and outfield) all played in more than 100 games and could start if Toronto elects to use a lefthanded pitcher. Castro, a switch hitter, stole a team-high 33 bases. Buxton (knee) is unlikely to make the roster.

Edge: Twins

PITCHING

Overview

The Twins led the majors in strikeouts (1,560) and Toronto was second (1,528). The Twins gave up the fewest runs in the AL (659) but Toronto gave up only 671. The Blue Jays had the better ERA (3.78-3.87). The Twins had a better WHIP (1.20-1.25). Toronto had four pitchers start 31 or more games; no other team had more than two.

STARTING PITCHERS

Blue Jays: RH Kevin Gausman (12-9, 3.16, 237 K), RH Chris Bassitt (16-8, 3.60, 186 K), RH José Berríos (11-12, 3.65, 184 K), LH Yusei Kikuchi (11-6, 3.86, 181 K).

Gausman used his devastating splitter to lead the league in strikeouts and will start Game 1. Berríos was a two-time All-Star with the Twins before going to the Jays at the 2021 trade deadline. Kikuchi provides a lefthanded option.

Twins: RH Pablo López (11-8, 3.66, 234 K), RH Sonny Gray (8-8, 2.79, 183 K), RH Joe Ryan (11-10, 4.51, 197 K), RH Kenta Maeda (6-8, 4.23, 117 K).

López was second in the AL in strikeouts and Gray was second (behind Gerrit Cole) in ERA. The third game starter is undecided; Bailey Ober has been sharper than Ryan or Maeda but seems likely to be left off the roster after pitching Sunday.

Edge: Toronto

BULLPEN

Blue Jays: Toronto got RH Jordan Hicks (1.08 WHIP) from St. Louis at the trade deadline to set up RH Jordan Romano (36 saves in 40 chances). RH Erik Swanson, LH Tim Mayza and RH Yimi García got a lot of work. Bullpen ERA is 3.67.

Twins: RH Jhoan Duran was 27-for-32 in save opportunities. RH Brock Stewart is rebounding from arm injury and RH Griffin Jax has been uneven and unlucky (10 losses in 71 appearances). RH Louie Varland had an impressive September, and Maeda could factor in as well. Bullpen ERA is 3.96.

Edge: Even

MANAGERS

John Schneider, Toronto: Led the Jays to the playoffs in both of his seasons; they were swept by Seattle last year.

Rocco Baldelli, Twins: The 2019 AL Manager of the Year is 375-333 in five seasons, and 0-5 in the playoffs.

Edge: Even

PREDICTION

The Twins have lost 18 consecutive playoff games, a North American sports record. Breaking that streak is the first step. López and Gray give them a strong 1-2 combo, but beating Gausman is probably the key. With the home-field advantage, Twins in three.

Toronto Blue Jays Vladimir Guerrero Jr. hits a single off Tampa Bay Rays relief pitcher Zack Littell during the third inning of a baseball game Friday, Sept. 29, 2023, in Toronto. (Chris Young/The Canadian Press via AP)
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. led the Blue Jays in most power categories, even though his runs, hits, home runs and RBI were down from last season. (Chris Young, Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Toronto Blue Jays third baseman Matt Chapman (26) was out at third as Minnesota Twins third baseman Kyle Farmer (12) made the tag for the second out of a double play in the seventh inning. The Minnesota Twins lost 3-0 to the Toronto Blue Jays in an MLB baseball game Sunday afternoon, May 28, 2023 at Target Field in Minneapolis. ] JEFF WHEELER • jeff.wheeler@startribune.com
Matt Chapman hit .240, his highest batting average since 2019, but his power numbers skewed lower. (Jeff Wheeler, Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Minnesota Twins center fielder Andrew Stevenson (45) headed for home with what proved to be the winning run on a double to right by Twins left fielder Trevor Larnach in the eighth inning. He was pinch running for Max Kepler. The Minnesota Twins defeated the Oakland Athletics 6-4 in an MLB baseball game Wednesday night, September 27, 2023 at Target Field in Minneapolis. ] JEFF WHEELER • jeff.wheeler@startribune.com
After hitting .207 in the first half, Max Kepler hit .306 in the second half for the Twins. (Jeff Wheeler, Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Toronto Blue Jays relief pitcher Jordan Romano, left, and catcher Danny Jansen react after a baseball game against the Baltimore Orioles, Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023, in Baltimore. The Blue Jays won 6-3. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
Jordan Romano made his second-straight All-Star appearance this season and struck out 72 batters in 59 innings while posting a 2.90 ERA. (Julio Cortez, Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

about the writer

about the writer

Chris Miller

Editor

Chris Miller supervises coverage of professional sports teams. He has been at the Star Tribune since 1999 and is a former sports editor of the Duluth News-Tribune and the Mesabi Daily News.

See More

More from Twins

card image
card image