Counterpoint
The Star Tribune recently ran a review of the Guthrie's production of "Charley's Aunt" in which the newspaper's critic spared little detail in his estimation of the show's lack of quality and his disagreement with the theater's creative choices.
Of course a theater such as the Guthrie is accustomed to a wide range of reaction to its work, but this article also contained a dismissive reference to the training received by graduates and students in the University of Minnesota/Guthrie Theater BFA Actor Training Program to which we feel compelled to respond.
For a full decade, our joint educational program has ably readied young performers for work at the highest level both in the Twin Cities and around the country. It attracts students from around the world, and is frequently on a short list of choices for bright young talent.
Critics across the country have been lavish in their praise for our graduates.
The Wall Street Journal's Terry Teachout said of Matthew Amendt (class of 2004, a star of "Charley's Aunt"): "Mr. Amendt is already more than good enough to make you wonder what he'll be doing, and where he'll be doing it, five years down the road"; Teachout was referring to Amendt's performance in the title role of the Hudson Shakespeare Festival's 2011 production of "Hamlet."
In March 2009, Charles Isherwood of the New York Times wrote of Amendt's work in "Henry V," again in the title role: "Fortunately, Matthew Amendt, who plays the role here, is a charismatic, skillful actor with a clarion baritone who gives the production a magnetic focus."
After seeing the work of Santino Fontana (class of 2004) in "Sons of the Prophet" in 2011, Isherwood called him "one of the most promising young actors to emerge in the New York theater in recent years."