Why were COVID air filter units removed from Minneapolis Public Schools — and what about in St. Paul?

Both school districts were able to tap pandemic relief money to improve air quality for students and teachers, and also have approached maintenance similarly in the past.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 6, 2024 at 2:00PM
An air filtration in a classroom is pictured at Harvest Best Academy, a Minneapolis charter school, in 2020. DAVID JOLES • david.joles@startribune.com Tuesday, Sept. 8, 2020, in Minneapolis, MN Students in masks, distance learning, teachers talking to cameras in empty classrooms, lessons in tents and behind plastic barriers -- the first day of school in 2020 is unlike any other. Most districts are starting Tuesday, the traditional day after Labor Day, and we capture the scenes with a series of vignettes.**Jaevon Walton,cq (David Joles/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

A new school year is underway in Minneapolis Public Schools, and COVID-minded people have been wondering: Where did the portable HEPA filter units go?

Turns out a majority of the district’s schools received filtration-system upgrades that now have them meeting CDC-recommended air quality levels, according to a recent notice to principals.

“With this improvement in building-wide air filtration, the portable units are no longer needed for exceptional indoor quality,” though a few remain available “if needs arise,” the message states.

HEPA filters became a classroom fixture nationwide three to four years ago as school districts — aided by an infusion of federal pandemic money — set out to boost indoor air quality to help protect students and teachers from COVID-19 and other viruses.

Not every Minneapolis school has shed its HEPA units, however.

Filters are in place buildingwide at Hale Elementary, Kenny Elementary and Lake Nokomis-Wenonah Community school, where wider improvements could not be made, the district said.

They also remain in select classrooms at eight schools: Anthony Middle School, Bryn Mawr Elementary, Dowling Elementary, Lake Harriet Lower Elementary, Las Estrellas Dual Language Elementary, Roosevelt High School, Sanford Middle School and Waite Park Elementary.

St. Paul

St. Paul Public Schools still has its HEPA purifiers in place and available for the staff to use, said Angela Vreeland, the district’s air-quality coordinator, who added their ability to filter out dust, pollen and viruses make them an integral part of the district’s indoor air quality strategy.

Some buildings, such as American Indian Magnet School on the East Side, have been fully renovated, and no longer require the purifiers, she said.

St. Paul also has used federal pandemic money to fund significant HVAC upgrades.

Since 2016, however, the district has relied on an approach inspired by Minneapolis that involves sending out a work crew to test and balance airflow in schools. For example, if a ceiling vent brings in outdoor air at a rate greater than designed, another is likely shorted, and air quality could suffer, Vreeland has said.

The testing, recalibration and retesting can take three to six months per building.

HEPA purifiers also can be deployed in rooms with less-than-optimal ventilation, Vreeland said.

St. Paul still has replacement filters on hand that were purchased with federal pandemic relief funds, which are set to run out by the end of the month.

about the writer

Anthony Lonetree

Reporter

Anthony Lonetree has been covering St. Paul Public Schools and general K-12 issues for the Star Tribune since 2012-13. He began work in the paper's St. Paul bureau in 1987 and was the City Hall reporter for five years before moving to various education, public safety and suburban beats.

See More